The results of the Pumpkin Pie-off

Having never baked before in my entire life, I was pretty pessimistic about my chances in the pumpkin-pie-off we had at work on Friday. The competition was pretty stiff, there are 4 Americans in the office, and each brought at least 1 pie, although a few people brought 2.  We ended up having 2 categories: pumpkin and pecan.


This is my pumpkin cheesecake. (I didn't add the whipped cream!)


I decided to make a pumpkin cheesecake pie, and while it was the crowd favourite, the judges had their doubts as to whether my entry should be accepted because it wasn’t strictly pumpkin.  So I won an honorable mention, but not the top prize (which was a bottle of rum!)


The competition. There were a few more pies to be added to the table, but this gives you an idea of the spread!


I also decided to make a pecan pie, because when you’re going to make a mess in the kitchen, it might as well be a big one!  Unfortunately my pecan pie didn’t turn out very well. I followed a recipe on the internet for SoCo Pecan Pie, because I figured that everything is better with alcohol in it, and considering the way the Brits drink, it might get me a few extra points.  But I think I must have made a mistake somewhere, because my pie was really dried out and crusty. It wouldn’t cut nicely, it just crumbled. Now, there was some debate because the recipe called for corn starch, which doesn’t exist in this country. After consulting the experts (thanks Mom!) I decided to use corn flour instead.  I don’t know if this had anything to do with the pie failure, but I doubt it.  I also may have translated the recipe wrong. You see, they don’t have tablespoons or cups or ounces here, everything is done in grams.  And as you all know, I’m not so good with the maths.


This is my pecan pie before I baked it. Doesn't it look yummy?

This is my pecan pie after baking. It got all dried out and crumbly.



Anyway, we all had a fantastic time eating the pumpkin pies. There was a lot of variety and flavour, and we pretty much all went home in a sugar-induced daze. I spent about 15 minutes trying to explain the concept of Black Friday to a co-worker, but he didn’t get it.  Also, no one really understood the pie to whipped cream ratio, which I believe is a firm 1-to-1.




Posted on 28/11/2010, in Foodie adventures and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.

  1. These pies came out great

  2. Oh yummy! I want a piece of the pumpkin cheesecake pie! Great tales for the adventures in “Off Continent Cooking” book. I am also craving cranberry mousse. Happy Non-Thanksgiving weekend. Valerie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s